Evaluating ERA5 wind direction with Copahue Volcano plume

Copahue is an active volcano in the Andes on the Chile-Argentina border. It erupted in 2016 and a plume of smoke was visible in many Sentinel-2 images during that period. Looking at these pictures I thought it would be fun to use that plume as a giant anemometer to evaluate climate model data.

Sentinel-2 image of Copahue Volcano on 2016-11-07

I extracted the wind vector from ECMWF ERA5 climate reanalysis available at the hourly time step in Google Earth Engine. Since Sentinel-2 overpass time is approximately 14h30 UTC in that area, I queried only ERA5 data corresponding to the 14h time step.

// Copahue volcano crater
var pt = ee.Geometry.Point([-71.18,-37.86]);

// filter a year of ERA5 collection at 14:00 UTC
var uv = ee.ImageCollection("ECMWF/ERA5_LAND/HOURLY")
.filterBounds(pt)
.filterDate('2016-01-01','2016-12-31')
.filter(ee.Filter.calendarRange(14, null, 'hour'))
.select(['u_component_of_wind_10m','v_component_of_wind_10m']);

// Plot U,V 
print(ui.Chart.image.series(uv,pt));

 

I downloaded this figure as a table, then extracted the wind vector of a few dates corresponding to cloud-free Sentinel-2 images in 2016.

 

 

ERA5 wind vector at Copahue Volcano at 14h UTC and Sentinel-2 images

The wind vector matches the plume direction only on 22 Jan and 21 Sep… That is a score of 2/7, ECMWF you can do better!

Note from ECMWF

Care should be taken when comparing this variable with observations, because wind observations vary on small space and time scales and are affected by the local terrain, vegetation and buildings that are represented only on average in the ECMWF Integrated Forecasting System.

[1] a more elegant solution would be to draw the wind arrows in GEE directly but I felt that would led me to catch Mrs-Armitage-on-Wheels Syndrom)

Plus d'actualités

Dates de fauche en France

En 2024, des collègues du Cesbio ont publié un article* sur la cartographie de la date de fauche en France en 2022 à partir des données satellitaires Sentinel-2.   Leur magnifique figure 10 a attiré mon attention. La version à haute résolution fournie avec l’article (2861 × 2911 pixels) correspond à une image dont les pixels font […]

Évolution du jour de déneigement dans les Alpes françaises et les Pyrénées

Les socio-écosystèmes des Alpes et des Pyrénées dépendent étroitement des fluctuations annuelles du manteau neigeux. En particulier, le moment de l’année où la neige disparait détermine le début de la saison de croissance de la végétation de montagne et donc la période des estives. Le changement climatique est en train de bouleverser ce rythme saisonnier. […]

BIOMASS, the third launched satellite mission designed at CESBIO !

After SMOS in 2009, and VENµS in 2017, the CESBIO laboratory is very proud to see its third proposed mission, Biomass, reach orbit. As always, it has been a long journey from the idea, at the beginning of the century, to the selection in 2013 as the seventh Earth Explorer Mission by ESA, to the […]

Rechercher